Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Who's the biggest terrorist...?

Country is shaken by the back to back bomb blasts in Bangalore and Ahmedabad.

People are already ready with solutions. “Ban SIMI” says one. Others say bring back some strong law like POTA. Some are blaming it on SIMI, Indian Mujahudeen OR HUJI, some on the current national ruling party and rest on the lack of a common federal intelligence agency.

So who’s the biggest terrorist group…SIMI, HUJI, Indian Mujahudeen OR some one else…?

Let’s move little away from the terror strikes. Lets talk about India in general, a country with 70% of its population living in villages and 60 % of its population earning their bread through agriculture. Govt. marks lots of funds in the budget year after year for the welfare of the farmers. But the daily news paper headings about the farmers committing suicides say the plight of the farmers aloud.

If not farming then what will they do….? Govt. says we will give you guaranteed jobs for 100 days in a year through National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS). Crores being marked for the rural employment guarantee scheme, but again the official machinery is found to be too greedy for the goddess Laxmi.

So where are all the funds going ? It’s going in the foreign education of the kids of our Netas, Europe holiday trips of bureaucrats and rest all in their safe bank accounts across the globe. So they are enjoying life over the miseries, plight and dead bodies of thousands and thousands of their own countrymen.

So who’s the biggest terrorist group…SIMI, HUJI, Indian Mujahudeen or our politicians and other government officials…?

Now let’s move to environment. India enjoys a very low per capita CO2 emission of 1.67 tones/capita. But the reality is that a relatively small wealthy class of 1% of the population in the country is hiding behind a huge proportion of 823 million poor people for the CO2 emissions. In an upper-middle-class house five air-conditioners hum to the tune of eight kilowatts of power which is enough to light two villages. Their driver picks up a fifteen rupee loaf of bread by driving a 3000 cc Pajero to the local market, using up two litres of fossil fuel that took three million years to form deep below the earth crust.

Upper and middle class are not ready to reduce their CO2 emissions, and by that they are not only contributing to global warming, but also denying the hundreds of millions of poor in the country, access to development. Moreover the climate change is threatening the poor communities with economic devastation in the form of floods, droughts and ruined harvests.

Upper and middle class are earning more money to pollute the environment more. Their aspirations are giving birth to shopping malls in every corner of all the big and medium cities, which are hungry energy guzzlers and produce tones of packaging waste. They are moving from two wheelers to cars, cars to bigger cars. With more earnings their cars just get bigger and more fuel inefficient and they move further away from the concept of public transport. Metropolitan cities are given preference over villages while doing electricity load shedding so that the riches can enjoy their air conditioners and other energy hungry gadgets, when a loan ridden farmer is waiting to run his irrigation equipment.

So who’s the biggest terrorist group…SIMI, HUJI, Indian Mujahudeen, our politicians and other government officials or you and me?

.

14 comments:

Unknown said...

Shantanu, you are right in bring out a holistic picture of the situation in our country. I feel that the bridge between the haves and havenots can be narrowed through a little generosity, that way each one of us are in some way responsible and not just blame the ministers and govt. officials, I don`t think much will improve on that front. Let us all pledge to do our little bit, in some form to help our motherland.

Anonymous said...

Dear Shantanu,

The gaps between the haves and the havenots is there to stay. Its an opportunistic world out there. If you stand, you are left behind.

Taking of our duties to our motherland, there are so many mothers denied a roof above their head by their very own kids.

How much ever generosity we show the begging hands will not stop... its a triving business in some places.

The netas have a chance and they are cashing-in in that. Its we.. we individuals who year after year elect them and go through the same turmoil again and again... and the best part is.. we never learn.

We still believe that Mayawati or Mulayalam or Arjun Singh can change the face of our country... but we forget that they are filling their own pockets at our own cost...

I can go on and on fretting about how the politicians are plundering the people... but its we people who are allowing that to happen.

Anonymous said...

Dear Shantanu,

You have explained your ideas very clearly and it was nice to read the facts.

I want to say something:

We have many types of issues within our family, area we live in, municipality, state government and central govt. and personal problems and professional as well.

So, In my thoughts - I don't think of impossible to achieve in next 10 years of changing all this overnight.

We have to do 80:20 RCA on the highest priority issues and resolve them one by one because if we attend or NGO or people of india fight for 1 issue at a time - They can gather a BIG force.

The problem is that we have only political parties organizing these force. We need people's representation without party name.

We don't have such culture or forum where people of india can raise their voice.

The media has so many issues that they won't finish in 24 hours.

We need a forum where people of india can raise their voice and the voice should go to the right places to trigger changes.

RTI act has given us a biggest tool and we need bodies who can help bring collective voice of people of india without politizing it for personal gains.

Anonymous said...

Shantanu, I am not convinced. The blog is just our age old problems. All of this problems didnt take a life in a second with a press of a button or some other ingenious way.

Question is who is going to take the responsibility to clean it up. I am one of unfortunate Indian who wants to change it but cant b`cos of family ties like others I am still a spectator.

Anonymous said...

The blog is well written but the fact that you have used the bomb blasts to bring out issues closer to your heart (pollution, farmer suicide, etc.) is probably not right.
Terrorism and greed of Politicians are two different issues terrorism as an issue is no less than greedy politicians.

Given a choice what you you resolve first? Terrorism or pollution?
There are no right answers to the above question but surely first I would want killing of innocent people to stop and then see if rural employment scheme is working or not.

LostinDreams said...

Hello Shantanu,
Excellent post and flow. Enjoyed it while I was reading it. Ended up nodding my head at every line. But just one opinion simillar to the one given by Kamlesh, the thought at which the blog started did not seem to be the one in the end. Given all the inputs and knowledge passed through the blog, yes, we need to do our bit to ensure that such terrorist attempts do not happen again, and your idea of having a central intelligence agency (hopefully better than RAW) may be the key. But the question in my heart remains, how do we make this happen?
PS: I feel you have touched a topic which could lead up another blog by each person reading it. :)

Anonymous said...

From www.nimbupani.us
Shantanu,

There is not only 1 aspect to this issue..

Education: Most of the india is not educated, education not only means going to school, but also aware about what is right and what is wrong, what are their rights

This leads to selction of wrong politicians (politicians as I dont think we have any leader as of now)

The system has lowered our expectations so much that if someone does the basic things we are so apprciative of that, look at our PM if he is not take bribe we call him amzing leader but wat abt his role as a PM that he can let the whole MY buying thing happen... is that not the duty of PM..but he is a saint..

We say and as i read in the comments here that people want to do smething but can't do because of daily duties thats the beausty of system, here in india you are not given any chance to think beyond basic stuff, howill the majority will think about the country or scoiety...look around you, whole country is burning. everywhere...somewhere it is religion, somewhere water, somewhere state, soemewhere language or intercaste...

and best part is our powerful media...which is biased and always judgemental, they are worse than ekta kappor's soap as there we know they are soap but todays is media is playing into the hands of corrupt politician or their foriegn investors... who is the biggest beneficiary of these attacks especially ahemdabad...terrorist and Media..

now a days media dont report it sells sensations...every news is breaking news...

I can go on for a long but to sum it up its time for a revolution or radical change else we will continue to move towards a black hole..

Regards
www.nimbupani.us

shuchi said...

hmmmmm. ....well yes bhaiya the ponits raised by u are very much in line to killing dozens of people thru a terror attack .....but there are still N.G.O's fighting for it ...but about terrorism which is totally in the hands of our dear civil police and intelligence agencies who are failing again and again to trap these happenings, i sometimes feel ki the time has come when people will have to privatize this whole affair i know i am drifting away from the points which you have written but still .....now terorism has become a household activity and it has come to our houses which is scary ....cant we do something to wake up the people whom we pay heavy taxes to keep us safe atleast ALIVE......

Shantanu Gupta said...

Great to so many comments on my thoughts...

People said that why i have compared terrorism with pollution and corruption....??

I wantedly compared politicians and the upper/middle population with terrorist as both are no less then terrorists. Out of our selfishness, just for some more comfort we are not ready to change ourselves. Be it saying complete NO to plastic bags, Or using public transport, or buying energy efficient appliances OR using water harvesting and composting at home…..

After practicing these things myself I felt that these are too easy to follow….But when I try to spread it to the people around, people give it a damn and such callous attitude for the country, environment and the poor of the people (which are most effected by the climate change) is NO LESS THAN A TERRORIST ACT…..

Terrorist are killing a few people here and there but by our stupid/ignorant acts we are causing danger to the life on earth….

Anonymous said...

Well...all of us are sensitive to the aspects mentioned in the blog as well have insight. Being aware or writing about it; will only provoke thought patterns. There is a dire need for ACTION...whose doing that?...Tough one to answer. Let us make a difference to people and environment around us; to start of with. Simple question for introspection - "how do we treat the person who comes home to help us with the household activities - washing dishes/clothes'?...We always has a valid reason to state why the individual should not get a weekly off or a holiday during festivals. When the help approaches us for a lil hike of Rs.50; people debate and find a reason to postpone the act. Even the food that is given to them, is more often stale:((...Consider the Corporate environment. We are so used to being pampered - we use paper cups for chai/coffee...we end up taking 2 cups, as the chai is hot. We fail to shutdown the system end of day. Lot of time we are not even sure, how much food we need to serve on our plates. Outcome being...we end out throwing the food into bins. If we are unable to take control of what's happening around us...who is accountable for it??

Anonymous said...

I wrote before above and writing again.

All of us are correct and our intentions are very good.

However, Let's agree that we have many things to learn from the western world.

They have created a very nice standard of living for each and every person starting from milk man to people who are billionaires.

So, what can turn around India?

1. Education is the key. If each one of us can help adopt 1 child and sponsor their education - act like a mentor - Things will start changing. Once it gets momentum, people and forces will join.

2. Culture - We need to stop manipulative and corruptive practices all the time. We need to start giving time to families and come back from office at 5.30PM. All this will bring a change in our day-to-day life with reduced stress we will feel more better and not exhausted.

3. Intelligence Agency - We need a world-class intelligence agency that can help protect the boundaries of india both from external and internal enemies.

But all this - We can discuss and satisfy ourselves.

What will happen - Next? NOTHING.

How things will change to action?

THIS IS THE BIG QUESTION.

We have to give action item to government of India who is a body to represent the Indians.

Gandhi always believed in MASS MOVEMENT that can bring any change. We have to do that. We have to force the govt. to ACT on important issues like Education etc.

At the same time, we have to ensure that this is not done for personal gain, or manipulated in anyways.

The risk is that we see around that most of the people we can buy them easily and this is what stops us from acting because we do not trust our fellow countrymen.

SO, PROBABLY THE FIRST THINK IS TO ATTACK CORRUPTION. IF OUR MINDS ARE CLEAN, WE WILL PROBABLY BE A BETTER COUNTRYMEN AND THINK FOR EACH OTHER TOO!

Prarthana Unkalkar Kaul said...

Hey Shantanu,

Must say.... Commendable post. Liked reading every sentence and true facts mentioned about the situation in our country. Let us try our best to contribute as much as we can and bring that change which might bring in a huge difference. Good luck to all like minded people to give their best shot!!!

Best regards,
Prarthana

Anonymous said...

you are right.corruption has deep roots in india,however we people in general need to be awared and combat it because our system is too low to stop disparity in india.

Amritpal Singh said...

very well written Paaji, very good thoughts ineed.

Although terrorism is a totally different thing, but if people die dut to any of our actions/decisions, we are responsible.

the need of the time is to educate people about the hazardous repercussions of our daily routine actions.

politicians are bigger than terrorists, when it comes to loss of life ... look at Bihar, everyone know (Including the Agriculture Minister of Bihar), the annual floods are coming, but nothing was done, result thousands dies & millions affected.

Chamunda devi temple stampede killed 100's, this was becuase of lack of management and poor administration.

Administration/Judiciary needs to be stronger, we need change

everyone needs (should try) to be good, and we have a good society.